Neil Peart is the best! He can play Jazz. He plays for Rush and he plays really hard music. Nobody else could play Rush music in the hole list. I have went to other best drummer web sites and they all said that Neil Peart is 1. Neil Peart is the best! Go Rush! 1974-2112
So, I’ve learnt that Neil Peart is the best because…”he can play jazz”! wow, amazing
Several guys on other sites are dissing Peart in favor of Portnoy and Mangini. Hey… They’re skilled but please, those two guys are top ten… MAYBE, but in all honesty they couldn’t carry Neil’s pissbucket. I spent 35 years seeing concerts, was even a roadie for the Stampeders, Randy Bachmann, and Red Rider several times. I saw Pink Floyd in 79 & 80 do their Wall tour and I think I’m still there, but nobody, and I mean NOBODY, can touch Neil Peart with a pair of hickorys. He could use stale licorice and use his eyelids to hold them and they still couldn’t come close… And Snortboy, I mean Portnoy, knew he was substandard to Neil. Get real people, use your grey matter (or what’s left of it, and accept the facts. Neil Peart is the best there is, the best there was, and the best there ever will be. (Thanks for that Bret Hart)
Danny Carey is laughing somewhere… while playing 4 Peart solos at the same time
Neil is so technically proficient and imaginative when it comes to drumming (and indeed lyric writing) that, like others have previously said putting him at number 4 isn’t really giving him anywhere near the amount of credit he deserves.
2. John Bonham
Shannon Leto at number one? ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Shannon doesn’t have the talent that Bonham had in his LITTLE FINGER. He shouldn’t even be in the top 100 drummers, it’s absolutely ridiculous. Bonham was the most influential drummer of all time, all modern drummers would have studied Bonham like their life depended on it. He’s influenced the likes of Dave Grohl (Who should be on this list anyway) Joey Kramer, Lee Kerslake, Tony Thompson, Tommy Lee, Peter Criss, Stewart Copeland, Chad Smith, Dave Lombardo and Brad Wilk… Some of the greatest drummers of today who quite frankly would outplay Shannon Leto blindfolded and with a single hand.
Here is my opinion on the top 10 best drummers. I will be judging them each by their skill level, creativity, and showmanship. I will also give the reasons for why I put them in each spot.
10. Phil Collins (Phil Collins, many know him as the drummer of the 70s rock band, Genesis, however, where he shined the most was when he became a solo artist in the early 80s. As a solo artist, he showed the world his magnificent ability to sing while drumming which is a rare skill to say the least and shows that he has some major skill. When it comes to his creativity and showmanship, he is very solid, if you listen to any of his drum fills, you will see the creativity he put into writing them).
9. Dave Grohl (The nicest guy in rock, lead singer of the Foo Fighters, and the drummer of many grunge/rock bands, Dave Grohl makes the number 9 spot due to his exceptional skill on the drums, creative drum fills, and top notch showmanship while on the drum set and off. Songs like Smells Like
Why isn’t Bonham #1? Also is it just me or are their about 7 names in the top ten I’ve never heard of? This list is a terrible representative of the best drummer of all time. Have you ever listened to one of Bonham’s drum solos? He does so much with such a small set and can continue like 4 different rhythms at the same time. He is the best.
Danny Carey can play 4 different John Bonham SONGS at the same time. 4 rhythms, lol…
The very best, bonham could pound those small drums, and the big bass drum, it sounded like The God of thunder.
3. Keith Moon
The Loon at 11th? You blokes realize that this is a list of DRUMMERS, right? Not people smashing sticks on surfaces and calling it art. As for Peart, the current #2 guy, he was inspired by the Master of Exploding Toilets himself. (For you kids that think music is just WUB WUB WEOOW that are voting for other drummers, that means Keith). Listen to Love, Reign O’er Me. That crashing sound you hear at the end is Moon flipping over and destroying his drumset, because he’s just that badass. Fully improvised, for no other reason other than destroying something.
Just because someone is inspired by someone else doesn’t make them better.
Keith does it without even thinking about it as he was a pure natural talent when it came to playing the drums.
Keith was and still is the master of Rock and Roll drummers.
We can all have our opinions and who we think is best and there are many, many fine drummers in this world. So enjoy them all and remember keith was the best of his time on this planet.
Definitely MY favorite of the three drumming legends. I have nothing against Peart and Bonham or their bands (Actually The Who is my LEAST favorite out of Rush, Zeppelin, and The Who), Keith Moon’s drumming just catches my ear the most out of the three. He had an incredible sense of rhythm, even when he was just seemingly slamming his drum sticks on anything in sight. He was destructive but still had control over everything he was doing. When he went crazy, he still kept perfect time and made it fun to listen to. It’s just so sad that he died so young and we never got to hear what music would have evolved into if he had been around to continue influencing young musicians while he was alive. But maybe it’s because he died so young that he’s well known and that he’s an influential drummer. I don’t know. I’m digressing and I guess I’ll just stop here.
He was the most musical Drummer on the planet. Speed is not everything. He certainly had speed and rhythm, but his drums where melodic and filled in as melody on most WHO songs. The way he tuned his drums and used fills to craft melody is unmatched. There is a difference of rhythm and melody. Keith had speed, rhythm and melody. Peart and Bonham I think would agree. This guy was a manic on drums!
4. Michael Portnoy
mike is the second best drummer in HISTORY. Only Neil Peart comes first. Anyone who disagrees is not a rock fan and you should keep your pathetic opinions to yourself. This genre is personified by Mike. I give Neil first place ONLY cause he did similar first. Mike took it to the next level and is the BEST nodern drummer. Im a big fan of death metal drummers like Origin and Pete Sandoval but overall no one can stand up to Mike Portnoy. Thanks Mike for the years of inspiration!
It’s called an opinion. In the rock genre, Peart and Portnoy may dominate, but then there’s Carey, Bonham, and Moon. And if you count every genre, then Buddy Rich would dominate all?
Mike certainly is one of the top drummers of all time. Neil Peart and John Bonham are the only drummers that could compare to Portnoy. Peart because of his overall talent and Bonham because of his style and how he revolutionized drumming (not to mention he was in Led Zeppelin and used only a single kick drum to play complex double kick fills). Let’s be realistic, the Rev and Shannon Leto are good, but shouldn’t belong on this list above Keith Moon, Thomas Lang, and Mike Portnoy. Thank god Peart is number one or else I wouldn’t see any hope for the future of drumming.
personally, I think its a tie between portnoy and mike mangini. look him up. lars ulrich sucks. portnoy is amazing. buddy rich is also an amazing and respectable drummer. those should be top 3. portnoy, mangini, and rich.
5. Buddy Rich
Buddy Rich is in a league of his own and easily surpasses every other drummer on the list.
His rolls were as smooth as milk and his dynamic range
And amazing stick control were awesome. Hearing Buddy play p diminuendo all the way to the edge of his snare drum with a sudden rimshot and heavy accent
Bomb on his bass drum was a mesmerizing thrill.
To those who write him off as a mere technical
Wizard, I suggest that you listen to his treatment
Of the lighter passages on ‘Channel One Suite’
‘I Can’t Get Started’ and ‘Wave’ and you’ll be treated
To some of the most impeccably tasteful subtle musicianship possible. I recall hearing Buddy play
An extended duo with pianist Teddy Wilson at Ravinia
Park on Chicago’s North Shore in which he used wire
Brushes exclusively. The delicate light touch of his playing was true poetic artistry.
I offer up the brilliant ‘West Side Story Medley’
And the aforementioned ‘Channel One Suite’
As examples of
Buddy Rich was the Holy Grail of drummers. Any one who attempts to put a drummer ahead of Buddy Rich is insane. You can sum it up this way before Buddy died he said in an interview this his Music will Sustain forever. Buddy Rich was Right on time when he said that. You listen to Buddy Rich today at this time and all of his drumming sounds just as fresh and unbelievalbe as it did when he once performed it. What We are hearing today in drumming is just the same as a Washing Machine stuck in the Rinse Cycle. Same thing over and over no Creativity just pure noise. Buddy Rich just take a listen if or when he did take a drum solo. The Buddy Rich drum solo was like a GOOD BOOK it had a beginning a middle to it that kept you reading and staying with that solo and of course Buddy would give you a breathtaking finish. Today the drum solos you are hearing are just like the GRAND FINALE of a Fireworks Show. All noise and all loud loud louder FIREWORKS. No beginning just the END and a lot of
What is there to say about Buddy that hasn’t already been said a million times over? He was the greatest rhythmic prodigy to have ever hit the skins. He almost single-handedly defined the way the instrument should be played: with graceful intensity. His technical prowess, showmanship, soloing ability, speed (that left hand! ), and sound are yet to be matched by any drummer. And his drive. Oh man, his drive. I’ve never heard someone kick and drive a band as hard as Buddy EVER. Papa Joe Jones, Sonny Payne, and Gene Krupa (who, by the way, should also be in the top 10) come close. Buddy was the king, and most drummers on this list would agree.
RIP Traps. You’ve inspired millions of drummers (myself included) to work ourselves to the absolute apex of our abilities.
There’s really no argument you can make as to why he shouldn’t be number 1 other than his personality and the kind of music he played.
He IS the best drummer on this list, but not everyone can dig jazz and I think we can all agree he was a bit arrogant.
6. Dave Grohl
If this were a list for underrated musicians, Grohl would have my vote. But as it’s a list for best drummer, he’s my second place choice (Favouring Peart). I certainly don’t think Grohl is the best drummer–but probably the most versatile and effortless in his style. Able to play any genre, with anybody, drumming for many different bands each who had a very unique style. He definitely knew how to work with what he had, however simple, and make it a masterpiece. This man does not get 1/billionth of the credit he deserves or should have.
People don’t consider Dave to be an amazing drummer purely because in Nirvana his drum parts were energetic however simple. Yet if you listen to of his solo’s or his work with queens of the stone age or them crooked vultures you’ll get a completely different idea. Dave an animal and power house behind a drum kit
What the hell is wrong with you people?! Dave Grohl will ALWAYS win, hands down, best drummer of all time. He’s the most talented man out there. He’s the most amazing person in the world, so kind and gentle yet wild and crazy. You gotta love Dave Grohl, he should definitely be number one on this list. Always.
Dave Grohl? Are you kidding me.. He couldn’t even play for the Begees.. This list is a Joke…
7. Glen Power
Anyone who has ever heard The Script, live or otherwise, can confidently agree with me in saying that Glen Power is a force to be reckoned with. Not only can he drum with incredible skill and talent, he can sing, write songs, and play the guitar and the piano. He is a living legend!
Glen is a versatile drummer who can drum to any music style. Not many drummers can sing such amazing harmonies and interact with the band and fans in the way he does while keeping a rhythm. Not only that, Glen is proficient in various other musical instruments including guitar and piano – he truly has a gift. As far as talent goes, he has bucket loads, turn that bucket upside down and he will give you a rhythm. Many of The Script songs have a powerful drum beat that is often simple yet effective. Always a clean sound and with a surname like Power – well it says it all! A very humble man and a truly underrated talent!
Glen Power is the only drummer who I can sit and watch doing his thing and be generally interested all the way through and that speaks volumes. Also he recently played live while being randomly blindfolded by his bandmate and never missed a beat. He not only plays but he sings and also has a versatile talent and can play piano as well. Need I give any more reasons why this man is a living legend and the best drummer to ever exist?+48
G’wan the Irish!
8. Lars Ulrich
Judging from the way the comments are written, it seems to me that those who voted for him are mainly Metallica fan boys who have probably never tried much of anything beyond Metallica. The guy is very sloppy and unoriginal. He is only at number 9 because he’s the drummer of the biggest metal band in history yet easiest to listen to. It is a shame considering how many legends are beyond him in ranking
Shouldn’t be anywhere near the top 100! He throws in random fills, he loses track of time, he replaced his ride cymbal with a China cymbal and uses it to mask his mistakes, he can’t play double bass, he simplifies down a song painfully so take him off the list!
Lars revolutionized drumming. Listen to their first album. Whiplash motorbreath metal militia nobody played that fast in rock or metal bands before. On ride the lightning he proved he could make musical songs like fade to black and for whom the bell tolls work. On master of puppets he perfected his technique of thrash/speed metal while still playing songs Luke sanitarium and the thing that should not be… And justice for all saw his musical ability soar through the roof. Listen to one, dyers eve, blackened, you’ll know what I’m talking about. On the black album he created great atmosphere with complementing all the other great players in Metallica’s sound. Its about serving the song with Lars and the rest of Metallica. They proved this with load and reload. He didn’t overplay. He let the other players do their thing. St. Anger is underrated in terms of his drumming. The title track heard him return partly to his thrash roots in the choruses. Frantic was also great. Death magnetic saw
Metallica is my favorite band. I love Lars (no homo) but he shouldn’t be in the top ten yes he’s better than most people but there are so many other great drummers and creators that can do so much better than him, he’s good but not top ten good
9. Dave Lombardo
Dave Lombardo is better, faster and more aggressive than Lars Ulrich.
He is in another level
Is the best and favorite metal drummer of all time
And SLAYER isn’t as mainstream as many bands here
Slayer is true, rude and aggressive metal
some of the stuff that he does on the kit is just amazing. Lars Ulrich and Joey Jordison are WAY overated
1. John Bonham
2. Niel Peart
3. Kieth Moon
4. Dave Lombardo
5. Mike Portnoy
6. Danny Carey
7. Ginger Baker
9. Terry Bozzio
10. Ian Paice
This list includes some of the drummers that don’t deserve to be in it. Then there’s Dave Lombardo. He deserves to be among the top three drummers. Right after Bonham. Rest I don’t care where you put them. If this guy would have been in a mainstream band, I wouldn’t be writing this. Because then the world would have already done what I am trying to do, and this comment of mine wouldn’t be needed.
Dave Lombardo and Lars Ulrich are the two greatest drummers of all time and Vinnie Paul is third
10. Ginger Baker
The best I ever heard and with the broadest scope in jazz, rock, African, Japanese etc. A true genius. Only the like of Buddy Rich compare and they weren’t nearly as wide in scope or as fanatically dedicated to their craft. A crazy genius and a great artist met in one! The first time I heard him I mentioned to the band member, listening to one of his long solos while sitting next to me, that he was the greatest drummer I ever heard and he said that he thought so too. I found out later that I was speaking to Eric Clapton. My opinion has never changed and I seriously doubt if Eric’s has either.
Masterfully combining very heavy, rolling rock beats with jazz feel and fine nuances. He pioneered rock drumming by infusing jazz musical sense and sensibility: never the repetitive, boring stuff you get so much of in pop and rock drumming today. Always varied, creative, and in the tradition of jazz ensembles a soloist and equal co-creator to most of the classic Cream hit-songs.
Ginger Baker at 80? Are you kidding? He invented the double-base and could play Jazz and Rock and was a GREAT musician. 90% of the names before him on this list, most of all, RINGO STARR make this list a joke. Ginger Baker could wipe the floor with Ringo. So could most drummers living today like Dave Grohl and Mike Starr.
What a terrible list.
The best Drummer of times.
Unique. He was a true musician, a so writer, a composer not just drums player. And as I see number one is Neil Peart who said when they asked him about Baker, ” I wanted to be like him and that’s why I become a Drummer”. I guess that says it all